Understanding COGS Variance in Accounting

Key Takeaways

• COGS variance helps finance teams understand why actual production or inventory costs differ from expectations.
  
  
• Breaking COGS variance into volume, mix, and rate components reveals the true root cause.
  
  
• COGS variances often stem from supplier pricing, production inefficiencies, product mix shifts, or inaccurate forecasting.
  
  
• Acting on COGS variance insights helps organizations control margins, maintain cost discipline, and strengthen forecasting accuracy.
  
  
• FloQast Variance Analysis centralizes COGS variance workflows, documentation, and approvals, improving both speed and auditability.
  
  

Why COGS Variance Matters — And What This Article Builds On

If you're looking for the basics of Cost of Goods Sold, how it's calculated, and how it fits into financial reporting, start with our core article on What Is Cost of Goods Sold (COGS)?

This article goes deeper. Here, we focus on COGS variance, why it happens, how to break it down properly, and what actions accounting teams should take to keep costs under control.

As companies scale operations, introduce new product lines, or experience supply chain volatility, understanding COGS variance becomes essential for:

• Protecting margins
  
  
• Planning production levels
  
  
• Negotiating with suppliers
  
  
• Improving forecasting accuracy
  
  

COGS variance is one of the most important components of overall variance analysis, which you can explore further via our Variance Analysis product page.

What Is COGS Variance? A Quick Refresher

COGS variance measures the difference between actual COGS and expected or budgeted COGS.

Variance = Actual COGS – Standard (or Budgeted) COGS

• A favorable variance means costs were lower than expected.
• An unfavorable variance means costs were higher, often impacting margins directly.

However, the number alone is not enough.

To understand why COGS drifted from expectations, companies need to break the variance down into its three key components:

1. Volume variance
   
   
2. Mix variance
   
   
3. Rate variance
   
   

This method, common in cost accounting, helps isolate the true operational and financial driver behind the variance.

The Three Key Components of COGS Variance

Below is the standard industry breakdown used by cost accountants and FP&A teams.

1. Volume Variance

Volume variance reflects the impact of selling more or fewer units than planned.

How It Happens

• Higher volume → total COGS increases
  
  
• Lower volume → total COGS decreases
  
  

But this does not always reflect operational inefficiency. Volume variance often ties directly to:

• Demand changes
  
  
• Seasonality
  
  
• Sales performance
  
  
• Inventory availability
  
  

When To Investigate

• Large swings in unit sales
  
  
• Stockouts causing forced production changes
  
  
• Unexpected declines in customer demand
  
  

Example Action

An unfavorable volume variance may signal the need to re-evaluate sales forecasts or adjust production levels to avoid overproduction.

2. Product Mix Variance

Mix variance occurs when the ratio of products sold differs from the original plan or budget.

Why It Matters

Products often have different cost structures.

Selling more high-cost products, even if sales volume is strong, can create an unfavorable COGS variance.

Common Causes

• Shifts in customer preference
  
  
• Promotional campaigns focused on certain SKUs
  
  
• Supply chain constraints affecting product availability
  
  
• Changes in the pricing strategy
  
  

Example Action

A persistent mix variance could prompt:

• A re-evaluation of pricing strategies
  
  
• Adjustments to product bundling
  
  
• A conversation with Sales Ops to align promotions with margin goals
  
  

3. Rate Variance

Rate variance is the difference between actual input costs (materials, labor, freight, warehousing, manufacturing) and budgeted or standard rates.

Primary Drivers

• Supplier price increases
  
  
• Commodity cost fluctuations
  
  
• Transportation volatility
  
  
• Labor rate changes
  
  
• Warehouse/storage cost shifts
  
  

Why It’s Critical

Rate variance often impacts gross margin most significantly because it reflects true underlying cost inflation.

Example Action

A material rate variance may lead to:

• Supplier renegotiations
  
  
• Volume purchasing agreements
  
  
• Updating standard costs for more accurate forecasting
  
  
• Reassessing production footprint or logistics vendors
  
  

Putting It All Together — Diagnosing the Root Cause

After breaking COGS variance into volume, mix, and rate components, finance teams can determine:

• Is this a pricing problem?
  
  
• A forecasting miss?
  
  
• A production efficiency issue?
  
  
• A demand/mix shift from Sales?
  
  
• An external supply-chain impact?

This clarity allows teams to take targeted, meaningful action—instead of relying on generic explanations like “higher costs than expected.”

This is where FloQast Variance Analysis adds value:

• Standardizing explanations
  
  
• Centralizing workflows
  
  
• Assigning ownership
  
  
• Tracking supporting documentation
  
  
• Improving audit readiness
  
  

Tips for Keeping COGS Variances Under Control

Once teams understand what’s causing COGS variance, the next step is tightening controls and strengthening forecasting.

1. Update Standard Costs More Frequently

Many teams only update standards annually, but in volatile markets, updating quarterly, or even monthly, provides far more accurate variance analysis.

2. Strengthen Supplier Management

Rate variances often stem from unmonitored supplier increases.

Actions include:

• Reviewing vendor scorecards
  
  
• Locking in long-term pricing
  
  
• Diversifying suppliers
  
  

3. Improve Forecast Collaboration Across Teams

COGS ties directly to demand, pricing, production, and supply chain.

That means FP&A, Sales, and Operations should be involved in the forecasting cycle, not only Accounting.

4. Automate COGS Variance Reviews

Manual COGS analysis is time-consuming.

Automating with FloQast helps:

• Flag threshold breaches
  
  
• Assign explanations
  
  
• Reduce back-and-forth during close
  
  
• Consolidate variance narratives
  
  

5. Conduct Regular Mix and Rate Analysis

Even if total COGS looks normal, mix or rate variances may hide underlying margin risks.

Periodic reviews help maintain pricing and profit stability.

Final Thoughts: COGS Variance as a Strategic Lever

COGS variance isn’t just an accounting task, it's a margin protection tool.

When broken down properly into volume, mix, and rate, it becomes one of the clearest signals of operational performance, pricing stability, and financial health.

Whether you're diagnosing sudden spikes in material costs, uncovering product mix issues, or aligning forecasts with real operational drivers, staying on top of COGS variances is essential for confident decision-making.

Strengthen your variance workflows, tighten cost visibility, and support a faster, more accurate close.

Take the next step! Get a Demo and see how FloQast brings clarity and automation to COGS variance analysis.

‍